Management of user and stakeholder interests in multi criteria assessments

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Individual user and stakeholder interests in the context of project requirements and goals often lead to trade-offs; especially during the early design stage of a building. Investors for example strive to achieve a maximum sustainability assessment score on the one hand and optimized initial costs on the other. Users often prefer good indoor environment conditions and low operating costs. A systematic approach is called for in order to achieve both, a high level of stakeholder satisfaction on the one hand and a high performance in the context of sustainability-assessment on the other. We applied a new approach linking building assessment and network analysis based on the Austrian building assessment system (ÖGNI/DGNB) and using a reference project of a public office building in Austria. Giving full consideration to the individual user and stakeholder goals the determination of sustainability performance is carried out by scenario analysis taking into account criteria interdependency. Depending on the investigated scenarios for improvement representing stakeholder influence, the results indicate an optimization potential of ÖGNI/DGNB target achievement between 1.3 and 5.2%. Systemic influence caused by different optimization strategies on single assessment criteria is an important aspect for the sustainability improvement of buildings. Arising as a result of system trade-offs, inappropriate optimization scenarios – induced by users and stakeholder goals – improve the instantaneously assessed criterion but simultaneously these can lower overall building sustainability. A balanced improvement of all assessment areas is thus indispensable to ensure a high assessment level already in early planning stages and furthermore to achieve stakeholder satisfaction.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationSustainable Built Environment (SBE) regional conference
Publishervdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zürich
Pages490-495
Number of pages6
Publication statusPublished - 2016
EventSBE16 Zurich - ETH Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland
Duration: 13 Jun 201617 Jun 2016

Conference

ConferenceSBE16 Zurich
CountrySwitzerland
CityZürich
Period13/06/1617/06/16

Keywords

    Fields of Expertise

    • Sustainable Systems

    Cite this

    Kreiner, H., & Passer, A. (2016). Management of user and stakeholder interests in multi criteria assessments. In Sustainable Built Environment (SBE) regional conference (pp. 490-495). vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zürich.

    Management of user and stakeholder interests in multi criteria assessments. / Kreiner, Helmuth; Passer, Alexander.

    Sustainable Built Environment (SBE) regional conference. vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zürich, 2016. p. 490-495.

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionResearchpeer-review

    Kreiner, H & Passer, A 2016, Management of user and stakeholder interests in multi criteria assessments. in Sustainable Built Environment (SBE) regional conference. vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zürich, pp. 490-495, SBE16 Zurich, Zürich, Switzerland, 13/06/16.
    Kreiner H, Passer A. Management of user and stakeholder interests in multi criteria assessments. In Sustainable Built Environment (SBE) regional conference. vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zürich. 2016. p. 490-495
    Kreiner, Helmuth ; Passer, Alexander. / Management of user and stakeholder interests in multi criteria assessments. Sustainable Built Environment (SBE) regional conference. vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zürich, 2016. pp. 490-495
    @inproceedings{cbcd89b2ae1a481d98d2b5c2221957dc,
    title = "Management of user and stakeholder interests in multi criteria assessments",
    abstract = "Individual user and stakeholder interests in the context of project requirements and goals often lead to trade-offs; especially during the early design stage of a building. Investors for example strive to achieve a maximum sustainability assessment score on the one hand and optimized initial costs on the other. Users often prefer good indoor environment conditions and low operating costs. A systematic approach is called for in order to achieve both, a high level of stakeholder satisfaction on the one hand and a high performance in the context of sustainability-assessment on the other. We applied a new approach linking building assessment and network analysis based on the Austrian building assessment system ({\"O}GNI/DGNB) and using a reference project of a public office building in Austria. Giving full consideration to the individual user and stakeholder goals the determination of sustainability performance is carried out by scenario analysis taking into account criteria interdependency. Depending on the investigated scenarios for improvement representing stakeholder influence, the results indicate an optimization potential of {\"O}GNI/DGNB target achievement between 1.3 and 5.2{\%}. Systemic influence caused by different optimization strategies on single assessment criteria is an important aspect for the sustainability improvement of buildings. Arising as a result of system trade-offs, inappropriate optimization scenarios – induced by users and stakeholder goals – improve the instantaneously assessed criterion but simultaneously these can lower overall building sustainability. A balanced improvement of all assessment areas is thus indispensable to ensure a high assessment level already in early planning stages and furthermore to achieve stakeholder satisfaction.",
    keywords = "lca, lcc, multi-criteria design, sustainability assessment, systemic approach",
    author = "Helmuth Kreiner and Alexander Passer",
    year = "2016",
    language = "English",
    pages = "490--495",
    booktitle = "Sustainable Built Environment (SBE) regional conference",
    publisher = "vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Z{\"u}rich",

    }

    TY - GEN

    T1 - Management of user and stakeholder interests in multi criteria assessments

    AU - Kreiner, Helmuth

    AU - Passer, Alexander

    PY - 2016

    Y1 - 2016

    N2 - Individual user and stakeholder interests in the context of project requirements and goals often lead to trade-offs; especially during the early design stage of a building. Investors for example strive to achieve a maximum sustainability assessment score on the one hand and optimized initial costs on the other. Users often prefer good indoor environment conditions and low operating costs. A systematic approach is called for in order to achieve both, a high level of stakeholder satisfaction on the one hand and a high performance in the context of sustainability-assessment on the other. We applied a new approach linking building assessment and network analysis based on the Austrian building assessment system (ÖGNI/DGNB) and using a reference project of a public office building in Austria. Giving full consideration to the individual user and stakeholder goals the determination of sustainability performance is carried out by scenario analysis taking into account criteria interdependency. Depending on the investigated scenarios for improvement representing stakeholder influence, the results indicate an optimization potential of ÖGNI/DGNB target achievement between 1.3 and 5.2%. Systemic influence caused by different optimization strategies on single assessment criteria is an important aspect for the sustainability improvement of buildings. Arising as a result of system trade-offs, inappropriate optimization scenarios – induced by users and stakeholder goals – improve the instantaneously assessed criterion but simultaneously these can lower overall building sustainability. A balanced improvement of all assessment areas is thus indispensable to ensure a high assessment level already in early planning stages and furthermore to achieve stakeholder satisfaction.

    AB - Individual user and stakeholder interests in the context of project requirements and goals often lead to trade-offs; especially during the early design stage of a building. Investors for example strive to achieve a maximum sustainability assessment score on the one hand and optimized initial costs on the other. Users often prefer good indoor environment conditions and low operating costs. A systematic approach is called for in order to achieve both, a high level of stakeholder satisfaction on the one hand and a high performance in the context of sustainability-assessment on the other. We applied a new approach linking building assessment and network analysis based on the Austrian building assessment system (ÖGNI/DGNB) and using a reference project of a public office building in Austria. Giving full consideration to the individual user and stakeholder goals the determination of sustainability performance is carried out by scenario analysis taking into account criteria interdependency. Depending on the investigated scenarios for improvement representing stakeholder influence, the results indicate an optimization potential of ÖGNI/DGNB target achievement between 1.3 and 5.2%. Systemic influence caused by different optimization strategies on single assessment criteria is an important aspect for the sustainability improvement of buildings. Arising as a result of system trade-offs, inappropriate optimization scenarios – induced by users and stakeholder goals – improve the instantaneously assessed criterion but simultaneously these can lower overall building sustainability. A balanced improvement of all assessment areas is thus indispensable to ensure a high assessment level already in early planning stages and furthermore to achieve stakeholder satisfaction.

    KW - lca

    KW - lcc

    KW - multi-criteria design

    KW - sustainability assessment

    KW - systemic approach

    UR - http://vdf.ch/expanding-boundaries.html

    M3 - Conference contribution

    SP - 490

    EP - 495

    BT - Sustainable Built Environment (SBE) regional conference

    PB - vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zürich

    ER -