Improving the behavioral realism of global integrated assessment models: An application to consumers’ vehicle choices

David L. McCollum, Charlie Wilson, Hazel Pettifor, Kalai Ramea, Volker Krey, Keywan Riahi, Christoph Bertram, Zhenhong Lin, Oreane Y. Edelenbosch, Sei Fujisawa

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

A large body of transport sector-focused research recognizes the complexity of human behavior in relation to mobility. Yet, global integrated assessment models (IAMs), which are widely used to evaluate the costs, potentials, and consequences of different greenhouse gas emission trajectories over the medium-to-long term, typically represent behavior and the end use of energy as a simple rational choice between available alternatives, even though abundant empirical evidence shows that real-world decision making is more complex and less routinely rational. This paper demonstrates the value of incorporating certain features of consumer behavior in IAMs, focusing on light-duty vehicle (LDV) purchase decisions. An innovative model formulation is developed to represent heterogeneous consumer groups with varying preferences for vehicle novelty, range, refueling/recharging availability, and variety. The formulation is then implemented in the transport module of MESSAGE-Transport, a global IAM, although it also has the generic flexibility to be applied in energy-economy models with varying set-ups. Comparison of conventional and ‘behaviorally-realistic’ model runs with respect to vehicle purchase decisions shows that consumer preferences may slow down the transition to alternative fuel (low-carbon) vehicles. Consequently, stronger price-based incentives and/or non-price based measures may be needed to transform the global fleet of passenger vehicles, at least in the initial market phases of novel alternatives. Otherwise, the mitigation burden borne by other transport sub-sectors and other energy sectors could be higher than previously estimated. More generally, capturing behavioral features of energy consumers in global IAMs increases their usefulness to policy makers by allowing a more realistic assessment of a more diverse suite of policies.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)322-342
Number of pages21
JournalTransportation Research / D
Volume55
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2017

Fingerprint

realism
energy
purchase
Consumer behavior
consumption behavior
alternative fuel
human behavior
Alternative fuels
vehicle
Gas emissions
Greenhouse gases
incentive
greenhouse gas
mitigation
flexibility
transform
Decision making
trajectory
Trajectories
decision making

Keywords

  • Climate change mitigation
  • Consumer choice
  • Human behavior
  • Light-duty vehicles
  • Transport

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Civil and Structural Engineering
  • Transportation
  • Environmental Science(all)

Cite this

Improving the behavioral realism of global integrated assessment models : An application to consumers’ vehicle choices. / McCollum, David L.; Wilson, Charlie; Pettifor, Hazel; Ramea, Kalai; Krey, Volker; Riahi, Keywan; Bertram, Christoph; Lin, Zhenhong; Edelenbosch, Oreane Y.; Fujisawa, Sei.

In: Transportation Research / D, Vol. 55, 01.08.2017, p. 322-342.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

McCollum, DL, Wilson, C, Pettifor, H, Ramea, K, Krey, V, Riahi, K, Bertram, C, Lin, Z, Edelenbosch, OY & Fujisawa, S 2017, 'Improving the behavioral realism of global integrated assessment models: An application to consumers’ vehicle choices' Transportation Research / D, vol. 55, pp. 322-342. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trd.2016.04.003
McCollum, David L. ; Wilson, Charlie ; Pettifor, Hazel ; Ramea, Kalai ; Krey, Volker ; Riahi, Keywan ; Bertram, Christoph ; Lin, Zhenhong ; Edelenbosch, Oreane Y. ; Fujisawa, Sei. / Improving the behavioral realism of global integrated assessment models : An application to consumers’ vehicle choices. In: Transportation Research / D. 2017 ; Vol. 55. pp. 322-342.
@article{187eb97743c944629878d98d22771a03,
title = "Improving the behavioral realism of global integrated assessment models: An application to consumers’ vehicle choices",
abstract = "A large body of transport sector-focused research recognizes the complexity of human behavior in relation to mobility. Yet, global integrated assessment models (IAMs), which are widely used to evaluate the costs, potentials, and consequences of different greenhouse gas emission trajectories over the medium-to-long term, typically represent behavior and the end use of energy as a simple rational choice between available alternatives, even though abundant empirical evidence shows that real-world decision making is more complex and less routinely rational. This paper demonstrates the value of incorporating certain features of consumer behavior in IAMs, focusing on light-duty vehicle (LDV) purchase decisions. An innovative model formulation is developed to represent heterogeneous consumer groups with varying preferences for vehicle novelty, range, refueling/recharging availability, and variety. The formulation is then implemented in the transport module of MESSAGE-Transport, a global IAM, although it also has the generic flexibility to be applied in energy-economy models with varying set-ups. Comparison of conventional and ‘behaviorally-realistic’ model runs with respect to vehicle purchase decisions shows that consumer preferences may slow down the transition to alternative fuel (low-carbon) vehicles. Consequently, stronger price-based incentives and/or non-price based measures may be needed to transform the global fleet of passenger vehicles, at least in the initial market phases of novel alternatives. Otherwise, the mitigation burden borne by other transport sub-sectors and other energy sectors could be higher than previously estimated. More generally, capturing behavioral features of energy consumers in global IAMs increases their usefulness to policy makers by allowing a more realistic assessment of a more diverse suite of policies.",
keywords = "Climate change mitigation, Consumer choice, Human behavior, Light-duty vehicles, Transport",
author = "McCollum, {David L.} and Charlie Wilson and Hazel Pettifor and Kalai Ramea and Volker Krey and Keywan Riahi and Christoph Bertram and Zhenhong Lin and Edelenbosch, {Oreane Y.} and Sei Fujisawa",
year = "2017",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.trd.2016.04.003",
language = "English",
volume = "55",
pages = "322--342",
journal = "Transportation Research / D",
issn = "1361-9209",
publisher = "Elsevier B.V.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Improving the behavioral realism of global integrated assessment models

T2 - An application to consumers’ vehicle choices

AU - McCollum, David L.

AU - Wilson, Charlie

AU - Pettifor, Hazel

AU - Ramea, Kalai

AU - Krey, Volker

AU - Riahi, Keywan

AU - Bertram, Christoph

AU - Lin, Zhenhong

AU - Edelenbosch, Oreane Y.

AU - Fujisawa, Sei

PY - 2017/8/1

Y1 - 2017/8/1

N2 - A large body of transport sector-focused research recognizes the complexity of human behavior in relation to mobility. Yet, global integrated assessment models (IAMs), which are widely used to evaluate the costs, potentials, and consequences of different greenhouse gas emission trajectories over the medium-to-long term, typically represent behavior and the end use of energy as a simple rational choice between available alternatives, even though abundant empirical evidence shows that real-world decision making is more complex and less routinely rational. This paper demonstrates the value of incorporating certain features of consumer behavior in IAMs, focusing on light-duty vehicle (LDV) purchase decisions. An innovative model formulation is developed to represent heterogeneous consumer groups with varying preferences for vehicle novelty, range, refueling/recharging availability, and variety. The formulation is then implemented in the transport module of MESSAGE-Transport, a global IAM, although it also has the generic flexibility to be applied in energy-economy models with varying set-ups. Comparison of conventional and ‘behaviorally-realistic’ model runs with respect to vehicle purchase decisions shows that consumer preferences may slow down the transition to alternative fuel (low-carbon) vehicles. Consequently, stronger price-based incentives and/or non-price based measures may be needed to transform the global fleet of passenger vehicles, at least in the initial market phases of novel alternatives. Otherwise, the mitigation burden borne by other transport sub-sectors and other energy sectors could be higher than previously estimated. More generally, capturing behavioral features of energy consumers in global IAMs increases their usefulness to policy makers by allowing a more realistic assessment of a more diverse suite of policies.

AB - A large body of transport sector-focused research recognizes the complexity of human behavior in relation to mobility. Yet, global integrated assessment models (IAMs), which are widely used to evaluate the costs, potentials, and consequences of different greenhouse gas emission trajectories over the medium-to-long term, typically represent behavior and the end use of energy as a simple rational choice between available alternatives, even though abundant empirical evidence shows that real-world decision making is more complex and less routinely rational. This paper demonstrates the value of incorporating certain features of consumer behavior in IAMs, focusing on light-duty vehicle (LDV) purchase decisions. An innovative model formulation is developed to represent heterogeneous consumer groups with varying preferences for vehicle novelty, range, refueling/recharging availability, and variety. The formulation is then implemented in the transport module of MESSAGE-Transport, a global IAM, although it also has the generic flexibility to be applied in energy-economy models with varying set-ups. Comparison of conventional and ‘behaviorally-realistic’ model runs with respect to vehicle purchase decisions shows that consumer preferences may slow down the transition to alternative fuel (low-carbon) vehicles. Consequently, stronger price-based incentives and/or non-price based measures may be needed to transform the global fleet of passenger vehicles, at least in the initial market phases of novel alternatives. Otherwise, the mitigation burden borne by other transport sub-sectors and other energy sectors could be higher than previously estimated. More generally, capturing behavioral features of energy consumers in global IAMs increases their usefulness to policy makers by allowing a more realistic assessment of a more diverse suite of policies.

KW - Climate change mitigation

KW - Consumer choice

KW - Human behavior

KW - Light-duty vehicles

KW - Transport

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84964873886&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.trd.2016.04.003

DO - 10.1016/j.trd.2016.04.003

M3 - Article

VL - 55

SP - 322

EP - 342

JO - Transportation Research / D

JF - Transportation Research / D

SN - 1361-9209

ER -