Clinical evaluation of semi-automatic open-source algorithmic software segmentation of the mandibular bone: Practical feasibility and assessment of a new course of action

Jürgen Wallner, Kerstin Hochegger, Xiaojun Chen, Irene Mischak, Knut Reinbacher, Mauro Pau, Tomislav Zrnc, Katja Schwenzer-Zimmerer, Wolfgang Zemann, Dieter Schmalstieg, Jan Egger

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: Computer assisted technologies based on algorithmic software segmentation are an increasing topic of interest in complex surgical cases. However-due to functional instability, time consuming software processes, personnel resources or licensed-based financial costs many segmentation processes are often outsourced from clinical centers to third parties and the industry. Therefore, the aim of this trial was to assess the practical feasibility of an easy available, functional stable and licensed-free segmentation approach to be used in the clinical practice.

MATERIAL AND METHODS: In this retrospective, randomized, controlled trail the accuracy and accordance of the open-source based segmentation algorithm GrowCut was assessed through the comparison to the manually generated ground truth of the same anatomy using 10 CT lower jaw data-sets from the clinical routine. Assessment parameters were the segmentation time, the volume, the voxel number, the Dice Score and the Hausdorff distance.

RESULTS: Overall semi-automatic GrowCut segmentation times were about one minute. Mean Dice Score values of over 85% and Hausdorff Distances below 33.5 voxel could be achieved between the algorithmic GrowCut-based segmentations and the manual generated ground truth schemes. Statistical differences between the assessment parameters were not significant (p<0.05) and correlation coefficients were close to the value one (r > 0.94) for any of the comparison made between the two groups.

DISCUSSION: Complete functional stable and time saving segmentations with high accuracy and high positive correlation could be performed by the presented interactive open-source based approach. In the cranio-maxillofacial complex the used method could represent an algorithmic alternative for image-based segmentation in the clinical practice for e.g. surgical treatment planning or visualization of postoperative results and offers several advantages. Due to an open-source basis the used method could be further developed by other groups or specialists. Systematic comparisons to other segmentation approaches or with a greater data amount are areas of future works.

LanguageEnglish
JournalPLoS ONE
Volume13
Issue number5
DOIs
StatusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

Bone
Software
Visualization
bones
Personnel
Bone and Bones
Planning
jaws
human resources
Costs
Industry
planning
industry
Jaw
methodology
Anatomy
Technology
Costs and Cost Analysis

Keywords

  • Algorithms
  • Humans
  • Image Processing, Computer-Assisted/methods
  • Mandible/diagnostic imaging
  • Retrospective Studies
  • Software
  • Tomography, X-Ray Computed/methods

Cite this

Clinical evaluation of semi-automatic open-source algorithmic software segmentation of the mandibular bone : Practical feasibility and assessment of a new course of action. / Wallner, Jürgen; Hochegger, Kerstin; Chen, Xiaojun; Mischak, Irene; Reinbacher, Knut; Pau, Mauro; Zrnc, Tomislav; Schwenzer-Zimmerer, Katja; Zemann, Wolfgang; Schmalstieg, Dieter; Egger, Jan.

In: PLoS ONE, Vol. 13, No. 5, 2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Wallner, Jürgen ; Hochegger, Kerstin ; Chen, Xiaojun ; Mischak, Irene ; Reinbacher, Knut ; Pau, Mauro ; Zrnc, Tomislav ; Schwenzer-Zimmerer, Katja ; Zemann, Wolfgang ; Schmalstieg, Dieter ; Egger, Jan. / Clinical evaluation of semi-automatic open-source algorithmic software segmentation of the mandibular bone : Practical feasibility and assessment of a new course of action. In: PLoS ONE. 2018 ; Vol. 13, No. 5.
@article{e78bf2bb2f024ed9b21eacd11afba7b7,
title = "Clinical evaluation of semi-automatic open-source algorithmic software segmentation of the mandibular bone: Practical feasibility and assessment of a new course of action",
abstract = "INTRODUCTION: Computer assisted technologies based on algorithmic software segmentation are an increasing topic of interest in complex surgical cases. However-due to functional instability, time consuming software processes, personnel resources or licensed-based financial costs many segmentation processes are often outsourced from clinical centers to third parties and the industry. Therefore, the aim of this trial was to assess the practical feasibility of an easy available, functional stable and licensed-free segmentation approach to be used in the clinical practice.MATERIAL AND METHODS: In this retrospective, randomized, controlled trail the accuracy and accordance of the open-source based segmentation algorithm GrowCut was assessed through the comparison to the manually generated ground truth of the same anatomy using 10 CT lower jaw data-sets from the clinical routine. Assessment parameters were the segmentation time, the volume, the voxel number, the Dice Score and the Hausdorff distance.RESULTS: Overall semi-automatic GrowCut segmentation times were about one minute. Mean Dice Score values of over 85{\%} and Hausdorff Distances below 33.5 voxel could be achieved between the algorithmic GrowCut-based segmentations and the manual generated ground truth schemes. Statistical differences between the assessment parameters were not significant (p<0.05) and correlation coefficients were close to the value one (r > 0.94) for any of the comparison made between the two groups.DISCUSSION: Complete functional stable and time saving segmentations with high accuracy and high positive correlation could be performed by the presented interactive open-source based approach. In the cranio-maxillofacial complex the used method could represent an algorithmic alternative for image-based segmentation in the clinical practice for e.g. surgical treatment planning or visualization of postoperative results and offers several advantages. Due to an open-source basis the used method could be further developed by other groups or specialists. Systematic comparisons to other segmentation approaches or with a greater data amount are areas of future works.",
keywords = "Algorithms, Humans, Image Processing, Computer-Assisted/methods, Mandible/diagnostic imaging, Retrospective Studies, Software, Tomography, X-Ray Computed/methods",
author = "J{\"u}rgen Wallner and Kerstin Hochegger and Xiaojun Chen and Irene Mischak and Knut Reinbacher and Mauro Pau and Tomislav Zrnc and Katja Schwenzer-Zimmerer and Wolfgang Zemann and Dieter Schmalstieg and Jan Egger",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0196378",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
journal = "PLoS ONE",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Clinical evaluation of semi-automatic open-source algorithmic software segmentation of the mandibular bone

T2 - PLoS ONE

AU - Wallner,Jürgen

AU - Hochegger,Kerstin

AU - Chen,Xiaojun

AU - Mischak,Irene

AU - Reinbacher,Knut

AU - Pau,Mauro

AU - Zrnc,Tomislav

AU - Schwenzer-Zimmerer,Katja

AU - Zemann,Wolfgang

AU - Schmalstieg,Dieter

AU - Egger,Jan

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - INTRODUCTION: Computer assisted technologies based on algorithmic software segmentation are an increasing topic of interest in complex surgical cases. However-due to functional instability, time consuming software processes, personnel resources or licensed-based financial costs many segmentation processes are often outsourced from clinical centers to third parties and the industry. Therefore, the aim of this trial was to assess the practical feasibility of an easy available, functional stable and licensed-free segmentation approach to be used in the clinical practice.MATERIAL AND METHODS: In this retrospective, randomized, controlled trail the accuracy and accordance of the open-source based segmentation algorithm GrowCut was assessed through the comparison to the manually generated ground truth of the same anatomy using 10 CT lower jaw data-sets from the clinical routine. Assessment parameters were the segmentation time, the volume, the voxel number, the Dice Score and the Hausdorff distance.RESULTS: Overall semi-automatic GrowCut segmentation times were about one minute. Mean Dice Score values of over 85% and Hausdorff Distances below 33.5 voxel could be achieved between the algorithmic GrowCut-based segmentations and the manual generated ground truth schemes. Statistical differences between the assessment parameters were not significant (p<0.05) and correlation coefficients were close to the value one (r > 0.94) for any of the comparison made between the two groups.DISCUSSION: Complete functional stable and time saving segmentations with high accuracy and high positive correlation could be performed by the presented interactive open-source based approach. In the cranio-maxillofacial complex the used method could represent an algorithmic alternative for image-based segmentation in the clinical practice for e.g. surgical treatment planning or visualization of postoperative results and offers several advantages. Due to an open-source basis the used method could be further developed by other groups or specialists. Systematic comparisons to other segmentation approaches or with a greater data amount are areas of future works.

AB - INTRODUCTION: Computer assisted technologies based on algorithmic software segmentation are an increasing topic of interest in complex surgical cases. However-due to functional instability, time consuming software processes, personnel resources or licensed-based financial costs many segmentation processes are often outsourced from clinical centers to third parties and the industry. Therefore, the aim of this trial was to assess the practical feasibility of an easy available, functional stable and licensed-free segmentation approach to be used in the clinical practice.MATERIAL AND METHODS: In this retrospective, randomized, controlled trail the accuracy and accordance of the open-source based segmentation algorithm GrowCut was assessed through the comparison to the manually generated ground truth of the same anatomy using 10 CT lower jaw data-sets from the clinical routine. Assessment parameters were the segmentation time, the volume, the voxel number, the Dice Score and the Hausdorff distance.RESULTS: Overall semi-automatic GrowCut segmentation times were about one minute. Mean Dice Score values of over 85% and Hausdorff Distances below 33.5 voxel could be achieved between the algorithmic GrowCut-based segmentations and the manual generated ground truth schemes. Statistical differences between the assessment parameters were not significant (p<0.05) and correlation coefficients were close to the value one (r > 0.94) for any of the comparison made between the two groups.DISCUSSION: Complete functional stable and time saving segmentations with high accuracy and high positive correlation could be performed by the presented interactive open-source based approach. In the cranio-maxillofacial complex the used method could represent an algorithmic alternative for image-based segmentation in the clinical practice for e.g. surgical treatment planning or visualization of postoperative results and offers several advantages. Due to an open-source basis the used method could be further developed by other groups or specialists. Systematic comparisons to other segmentation approaches or with a greater data amount are areas of future works.

KW - Algorithms

KW - Humans

KW - Image Processing, Computer-Assisted/methods

KW - Mandible/diagnostic imaging

KW - Retrospective Studies

KW - Software

KW - Tomography, X-Ray Computed/methods

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0196378

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0196378

M3 - Article

VL - 13

JO - PLoS ONE

JF - PLoS ONE

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 5

ER -