Another Flip in the Wall of Rowhammer Defenses

Daniel Gruss, Moritz Lipp, Michael Schwarz, Daniel Genkin, Jonas Juffinger, Sioli O'Connell, Wolfgang Schoechl, Yuval Yarom

Research output: Research - peer-reviewConference contribution

Abstract

The Rowhammer bug allows unauthorized modification of bits in DRAM cells from unprivileged software, enabling powerful privilege-escalation attacks. Sophisticated Rowhammer countermeasures have been presented, aiming at mitigating the Rowhammer bug or its exploitation. However, the state of the art provides insufficient insight on the completeness of these defenses. In this paper, we present novel Rowhammer attack and exploitation primitives, showing that even a combination of all defenses is ineffective. Our new attack technique, one-location hammering, breaks previous assumptions on requirements for triggering the Rowhammer bug, i.e., we do not hammer multiple DRAM rows but only keep one DRAM row constantly open. Our new exploitation technique, opcode flipping, bypasses recent isolation mechanisms by flipping bits in a predictable and targeted way in userspace binaries. We replace conspicuous and memory-exhausting spraying and grooming techniques with a novel reliable technique called memory waylaying. Memory waylaying exploits system-level optimizations and a side channel to coax the operating system into placing target pages at attacker-chosen physical locations. Finally, we abuse Intel SGX to hide the attack entirely from the user and the operating system, making any inspection or detection of the attack infeasible. Our Rowhammer enclave can be used for coordinated denial-of-service attacks in the cloud and for privilege escalation on personal computers. We demonstrate that our attacks evade all previously proposed countermeasures for commodity systems.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publication39th IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2018
StatusE-pub ahead of print - 31 Jan 2018

Keywords

  • cs.CR

Cite this

Gruss, D., Lipp, M., Schwarz, M., Genkin, D., Juffinger, J., O'Connell, S., ... Yarom, Y. (2018). Another Flip in the Wall of Rowhammer Defenses. In 39th IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2018

Another Flip in the Wall of Rowhammer Defenses. / Gruss, Daniel; Lipp, Moritz; Schwarz, Michael; Genkin, Daniel; Juffinger, Jonas; O'Connell, Sioli; Schoechl, Wolfgang; Yarom, Yuval.

39th IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2018. 2018.

Research output: Research - peer-reviewConference contribution

Gruss, D, Lipp, M, Schwarz, M, Genkin, D, Juffinger, J, O'Connell, S, Schoechl, W & Yarom, Y 2018, Another Flip in the Wall of Rowhammer Defenses. in 39th IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2018.
Gruss D, Lipp M, Schwarz M, Genkin D, Juffinger J, O'Connell S et al. Another Flip in the Wall of Rowhammer Defenses. In 39th IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2018. 2018.
Gruss, Daniel ; Lipp, Moritz ; Schwarz, Michael ; Genkin, Daniel ; Juffinger, Jonas ; O'Connell, Sioli ; Schoechl, Wolfgang ; Yarom, Yuval. / Another Flip in the Wall of Rowhammer Defenses. 39th IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2018. 2018.
@inbook{4ce23375efcd4518942b8f281e44922e,
title = "Another Flip in the Wall of Rowhammer Defenses",
abstract = "The Rowhammer bug allows unauthorized modification of bits in DRAM cells from unprivileged software, enabling powerful privilege-escalation attacks. Sophisticated Rowhammer countermeasures have been presented, aiming at mitigating the Rowhammer bug or its exploitation. However, the state of the art provides insufficient insight on the completeness of these defenses. In this paper, we present novel Rowhammer attack and exploitation primitives, showing that even a combination of all defenses is ineffective. Our new attack technique, one-location hammering, breaks previous assumptions on requirements for triggering the Rowhammer bug, i.e., we do not hammer multiple DRAM rows but only keep one DRAM row constantly open. Our new exploitation technique, opcode flipping, bypasses recent isolation mechanisms by flipping bits in a predictable and targeted way in userspace binaries. We replace conspicuous and memory-exhausting spraying and grooming techniques with a novel reliable technique called memory waylaying. Memory waylaying exploits system-level optimizations and a side channel to coax the operating system into placing target pages at attacker-chosen physical locations. Finally, we abuse Intel SGX to hide the attack entirely from the user and the operating system, making any inspection or detection of the attack infeasible. Our Rowhammer enclave can be used for coordinated denial-of-service attacks in the cloud and for privilege escalation on personal computers. We demonstrate that our attacks evade all previously proposed countermeasures for commodity systems.",
keywords = "cs.CR",
author = "Daniel Gruss and Moritz Lipp and Michael Schwarz and Daniel Genkin and Jonas Juffinger and Sioli O'Connell and Wolfgang Schoechl and Yuval Yarom",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
booktitle = "39th IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2018",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Another Flip in the Wall of Rowhammer Defenses

AU - Gruss,Daniel

AU - Lipp,Moritz

AU - Schwarz,Michael

AU - Genkin,Daniel

AU - Juffinger,Jonas

AU - O'Connell,Sioli

AU - Schoechl,Wolfgang

AU - Yarom,Yuval

PY - 2018/1/31

Y1 - 2018/1/31

N2 - The Rowhammer bug allows unauthorized modification of bits in DRAM cells from unprivileged software, enabling powerful privilege-escalation attacks. Sophisticated Rowhammer countermeasures have been presented, aiming at mitigating the Rowhammer bug or its exploitation. However, the state of the art provides insufficient insight on the completeness of these defenses. In this paper, we present novel Rowhammer attack and exploitation primitives, showing that even a combination of all defenses is ineffective. Our new attack technique, one-location hammering, breaks previous assumptions on requirements for triggering the Rowhammer bug, i.e., we do not hammer multiple DRAM rows but only keep one DRAM row constantly open. Our new exploitation technique, opcode flipping, bypasses recent isolation mechanisms by flipping bits in a predictable and targeted way in userspace binaries. We replace conspicuous and memory-exhausting spraying and grooming techniques with a novel reliable technique called memory waylaying. Memory waylaying exploits system-level optimizations and a side channel to coax the operating system into placing target pages at attacker-chosen physical locations. Finally, we abuse Intel SGX to hide the attack entirely from the user and the operating system, making any inspection or detection of the attack infeasible. Our Rowhammer enclave can be used for coordinated denial-of-service attacks in the cloud and for privilege escalation on personal computers. We demonstrate that our attacks evade all previously proposed countermeasures for commodity systems.

AB - The Rowhammer bug allows unauthorized modification of bits in DRAM cells from unprivileged software, enabling powerful privilege-escalation attacks. Sophisticated Rowhammer countermeasures have been presented, aiming at mitigating the Rowhammer bug or its exploitation. However, the state of the art provides insufficient insight on the completeness of these defenses. In this paper, we present novel Rowhammer attack and exploitation primitives, showing that even a combination of all defenses is ineffective. Our new attack technique, one-location hammering, breaks previous assumptions on requirements for triggering the Rowhammer bug, i.e., we do not hammer multiple DRAM rows but only keep one DRAM row constantly open. Our new exploitation technique, opcode flipping, bypasses recent isolation mechanisms by flipping bits in a predictable and targeted way in userspace binaries. We replace conspicuous and memory-exhausting spraying and grooming techniques with a novel reliable technique called memory waylaying. Memory waylaying exploits system-level optimizations and a side channel to coax the operating system into placing target pages at attacker-chosen physical locations. Finally, we abuse Intel SGX to hide the attack entirely from the user and the operating system, making any inspection or detection of the attack infeasible. Our Rowhammer enclave can be used for coordinated denial-of-service attacks in the cloud and for privilege escalation on personal computers. We demonstrate that our attacks evade all previously proposed countermeasures for commodity systems.

KW - cs.CR

M3 - Conference contribution

BT - 39th IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2018

ER -