Accuracy Bounds for Array-Based Positioning in Dense Multipath Channels

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

The accuracy of radio-based positioning systems will be limited by multipath interference in realistic application scenarios. This paper derives closed-form expressions for the Cramér–Rao lower bound (CRLB) on the achievable time-of-arrival (ToA) and angle-of-arrival (AoA) estimation-error variances, considering the presence of multipath radio channels, and extends these results to position estimation. The derivations are based on channel models comprising deterministic, specular multipath components as well as stochastic, diffuse/dense multipath. The derived CRLBs thus allow an evaluation of the influence of channel parameters, the geometric configuration of the environment, and system parameters such as signal bandwidth and array geometry. Our results quantify how the ToA and AoA accuracies decrease when the signal bandwidth is reduced, because more multipath will then interfere with the useful LoS component. Antenna arrays can (partly) compensate this performance loss, exploiting diversity among the multipath interference. For example, the AoA accuracy with a 16-element linear array at 1MHz bandwidth is similar to a two-element array at 1GHz, in the magnitude order of one degree. The ToA accuracy, on the other hand, still scales by a factor of 100 from the cm-regime to the m-regime because of the dominating influence of the signal bandwidth. The position error bound shows the relationship between the range and angle information under realistic indoor channel conditions and their different scaling behaviors as a function of the anchor–agent placement. Specular multipath components have a maximum detrimental influence near the walls. It is shown for an L-shaped room that a fairly even distribution of the position error bound can be achieved throughout the environment, using two anchors equipped with 2×2-array antennas. The accuracy limit due to multipath increases from the 1–10-cm-range at 1GHz bandwidth to the 0.5–1-m-range at 100MHz.
Original languageEnglish
Article number4249
JournalSensors
Volume18
Issue number12
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

Multipath propagation
positioning
arrivals
Radio
Bandwidth
bandwidth
position errors
Antenna arrays
antenna arrays
interference
Anchors
Error analysis
linear arrays
rooms
derivation
Geometry
scaling
evaluation
Time of arrival
geometry

Cite this

Accuracy Bounds for Array-Based Positioning in Dense Multipath Channels. / Wilding, Thomas; Grebien, Stefan Josef; Mühlmann, Ulrich; Witrisal, Klaus.

In: Sensors , Vol. 18, No. 12, 4249, 2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

@article{2635163e8ac447e3b37ca7c703a5d1c5,
title = "Accuracy Bounds for Array-Based Positioning in Dense Multipath Channels",
abstract = "The accuracy of radio-based positioning systems will be limited by multipath interference in realistic application scenarios. This paper derives closed-form expressions for the Cram{\'e}r–Rao lower bound (CRLB) on the achievable time-of-arrival (ToA) and angle-of-arrival (AoA) estimation-error variances, considering the presence of multipath radio channels, and extends these results to position estimation. The derivations are based on channel models comprising deterministic, specular multipath components as well as stochastic, diffuse/dense multipath. The derived CRLBs thus allow an evaluation of the influence of channel parameters, the geometric configuration of the environment, and system parameters such as signal bandwidth and array geometry. Our results quantify how the ToA and AoA accuracies decrease when the signal bandwidth is reduced, because more multipath will then interfere with the useful LoS component. Antenna arrays can (partly) compensate this performance loss, exploiting diversity among the multipath interference. For example, the AoA accuracy with a 16-element linear array at 1MHz bandwidth is similar to a two-element array at 1GHz, in the magnitude order of one degree. The ToA accuracy, on the other hand, still scales by a factor of 100 from the cm-regime to the m-regime because of the dominating influence of the signal bandwidth. The position error bound shows the relationship between the range and angle information under realistic indoor channel conditions and their different scaling behaviors as a function of the anchor–agent placement. Specular multipath components have a maximum detrimental influence near the walls. It is shown for an L-shaped room that a fairly even distribution of the position error bound can be achieved throughout the environment, using two anchors equipped with 2×2-array antennas. The accuracy limit due to multipath increases from the 1–10-cm-range at 1GHz bandwidth to the 0.5–1-m-range at 100MHz.",
author = "Thomas Wilding and Grebien, {Stefan Josef} and Ulrich M{\"u}hlmann and Klaus Witrisal",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.3390/s18124249",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
journal = "Sensors",
issn = "1424-8220",
publisher = "MDPI AG",
number = "12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Accuracy Bounds for Array-Based Positioning in Dense Multipath Channels

AU - Wilding, Thomas

AU - Grebien, Stefan Josef

AU - Mühlmann, Ulrich

AU - Witrisal, Klaus

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - The accuracy of radio-based positioning systems will be limited by multipath interference in realistic application scenarios. This paper derives closed-form expressions for the Cramér–Rao lower bound (CRLB) on the achievable time-of-arrival (ToA) and angle-of-arrival (AoA) estimation-error variances, considering the presence of multipath radio channels, and extends these results to position estimation. The derivations are based on channel models comprising deterministic, specular multipath components as well as stochastic, diffuse/dense multipath. The derived CRLBs thus allow an evaluation of the influence of channel parameters, the geometric configuration of the environment, and system parameters such as signal bandwidth and array geometry. Our results quantify how the ToA and AoA accuracies decrease when the signal bandwidth is reduced, because more multipath will then interfere with the useful LoS component. Antenna arrays can (partly) compensate this performance loss, exploiting diversity among the multipath interference. For example, the AoA accuracy with a 16-element linear array at 1MHz bandwidth is similar to a two-element array at 1GHz, in the magnitude order of one degree. The ToA accuracy, on the other hand, still scales by a factor of 100 from the cm-regime to the m-regime because of the dominating influence of the signal bandwidth. The position error bound shows the relationship between the range and angle information under realistic indoor channel conditions and their different scaling behaviors as a function of the anchor–agent placement. Specular multipath components have a maximum detrimental influence near the walls. It is shown for an L-shaped room that a fairly even distribution of the position error bound can be achieved throughout the environment, using two anchors equipped with 2×2-array antennas. The accuracy limit due to multipath increases from the 1–10-cm-range at 1GHz bandwidth to the 0.5–1-m-range at 100MHz.

AB - The accuracy of radio-based positioning systems will be limited by multipath interference in realistic application scenarios. This paper derives closed-form expressions for the Cramér–Rao lower bound (CRLB) on the achievable time-of-arrival (ToA) and angle-of-arrival (AoA) estimation-error variances, considering the presence of multipath radio channels, and extends these results to position estimation. The derivations are based on channel models comprising deterministic, specular multipath components as well as stochastic, diffuse/dense multipath. The derived CRLBs thus allow an evaluation of the influence of channel parameters, the geometric configuration of the environment, and system parameters such as signal bandwidth and array geometry. Our results quantify how the ToA and AoA accuracies decrease when the signal bandwidth is reduced, because more multipath will then interfere with the useful LoS component. Antenna arrays can (partly) compensate this performance loss, exploiting diversity among the multipath interference. For example, the AoA accuracy with a 16-element linear array at 1MHz bandwidth is similar to a two-element array at 1GHz, in the magnitude order of one degree. The ToA accuracy, on the other hand, still scales by a factor of 100 from the cm-regime to the m-regime because of the dominating influence of the signal bandwidth. The position error bound shows the relationship between the range and angle information under realistic indoor channel conditions and their different scaling behaviors as a function of the anchor–agent placement. Specular multipath components have a maximum detrimental influence near the walls. It is shown for an L-shaped room that a fairly even distribution of the position error bound can be achieved throughout the environment, using two anchors equipped with 2×2-array antennas. The accuracy limit due to multipath increases from the 1–10-cm-range at 1GHz bandwidth to the 0.5–1-m-range at 100MHz.

U2 - 10.3390/s18124249

DO - 10.3390/s18124249

M3 - Article

VL - 18

JO - Sensors

JF - Sensors

SN - 1424-8220

IS - 12

M1 - 4249

ER -